35x12.5x17 vs 35x11.5x17 — Which Is Better?

[TrailJustin]

Hey y’all, I’m stuck between running 35x12.5x17 or 35x11.5x17 on the Tundra and wanted to see what everyone thinks.



Here’s what I’ve noticed so far:

35x12.5x17​

Pros:

• Looks wider and more aggressive
• Bigger contact patch = more traction off-road
• Feels more planted when towing or hauling

Cons:

• Heavier, worse MPG
• More stress on suspension
• More rubbing issues depending on your setup
• Steering feels a little slower

35x11.5x17​

Pros:

• Lighter and easier on the truck
• Better MPG and better road manners
• Easier to fit with less rubbing
• Still has the height of a true 35”

Cons:

• Not as much traction in softer terrain
• Not as aggressive of a stance

I do a mix of daily driving, hauling, fishing trips, and some off-road, so I’m leaning toward the 11.5 wide for easier fitment and better drivability. But the 12.5s definitely look better.

Anyone running either size on a 3rd gen? What are your thoughts? Any rubbing or regrets?

 

[BG]

I say 37" M/Ts all day.....